The Rings of Power: How It Can Avoid a Past Mistake with a Key LOTR Character

The Rings of Power on Amazon Prime Video is preparing for a second season. Amidst the excitement of Lord of the Rings (LOTR) followers, there are a few noteworthy topics to discuss, particularly in relation to Shelob, the enormous spider.

One iconic bad guy from the LOTR realm is Shelob. Her final motion picture appearance was in Peter Jackson’s The Return of the King. Shelob will now make a comeback in The Rings of Power. But the program must exercise extreme caution to avoid making the same mistake in a video game that occurred seven years ago. If this error is committed again, a lot of fans might get furious.

The Problem with Shelob’s Previous Appearance

For LOTR enthusiasts, Shelob is no stranger. When she engaged in combat with Frodo and Sam in The Return of the King, she had a significant impact. But in 2017, a contentious decision was made by the video game Middle-earth: Shadow of War, which depicted Shelob as a lady rather than a spider. Many supporters were not pleased with this choice. They believed that Shelob was not faithfully portrayed in the game and that too many artistic licenses had been made with Tolkien’s writing.

Now that Shelob is back on The Rings of Power, the show runs the risk of offending viewers once more if it handles her character poorly.The show has a lot to prove, and avoiding this previous error could help it win over Tolkien enthusiasts as the second season approaches.

A New Version of Shelob in The Rings of Power

Thankfully, it appears that a more realistic portrayal of Shelob will be shown in The Rings of Power. The show’s Isildur, played by actor Maxim Baldry, has revealed a few details regarding Shelob’s portrayal. He revealed in an interview that his character will battle Shelob in a pitch-black cave. Baldry clarified that Shelob will be a spider and not a woman, which is significant.

For people who were concerned about how Shelob will be portrayed, this is a huge relief. Shelob is a fearsome spider that has existed for thousands of years in Tolkien’s writings. She has lived in Middle-earth for a very long time and is the daughter of a creature known as Ungoliant.Shelob will be smaller in the episode than when she makes an appearance later in the timeline in The Return of the King because it takes place during the Second Age. She may be tiny, but she still poses a serious risk.

Why It’s Important Not to Repeat the Mistake

For The Rings of Power, it is imperative that the error from the video game Shadow of War not be made again. Reviews for the first season of the show were ambiguous, with some viewers taking issue with the imaginative alterations made to Tolkien’s narrative. The show’s makers must exercise caution before making any more alterations that can enrage viewers.

It’s a step in the right direction that Shelob is a spider, as Tolkien intended. But the show is already experimenting with some new ideas; for example, Shelob fighting Isildur, something that didn’t happen in the original books. The show must strike a balance between telling imaginative stories and honoring Tolkien’s literary contributions. If not, it can turn off the very fans it is trying to win over.

In summary

Shelob’s comeback is a significant development for The Rings of Power as the program gets ready for its second season. It’s a positive step to depict Shelob as the spider she truly is, rather than the blunder made in the video game Shadow of War. In addition to honoring Tolkien’s legacy, this choice may help the program win over those viewers who weren’t thrilled with the first season. The Rings of Power has the potential to be a well-liked addition to the LOTR universe because it adheres to the original plot while introducing new features.

FAQs